When a Re-Inspection Is Appropriate
Not every disagreement with your adjuster warrants a re-inspection. Minor pricing differences are usually handled through supplements. But certain situations clearly call for a second look at the physical damage itself.
Request a re-inspection when the adjuster did not inspect all areas of the roof. If they only climbed one slope, only checked the front face, or skipped the attic and interior, significant damage may have been missed entirely. You are not asking them to reconsider their judgment — you are asking them to inspect areas they did not examine.
Request a re-inspection when your contractor identifies damage that is clearly visible but absent from the adjuster's scope. This happens frequently during storm season when adjusters are handling dozens of claims per day. A re-inspection with your contractor present allows someone to point out each missed item in person.
Request a re-inspection when there is a causation disagreement. If the adjuster attributed your damage to wear and tear but your contractor identifies clear storm-related indicators — directional patterns, fresh fractures, impact marks consistent with the reported storm — a second adjuster may reach a different causation conclusion.
"If I request a re-inspection, the carrier will think I'm being difficult and it will hurt my claim."
Re-inspections are a standard part of the claims process. Carriers process them routinely. Requesting a re-inspection with clear, specific reasons and supporting documentation shows you are engaged and informed — not difficult. The carrier may send a more senior adjuster for the re-inspection, which can actually work in your favor.
Homeowners who avoid requesting re-inspections because they worry about perception may accept incomplete scopes that undervalue their damage by thousands of dollars.
The 5-Step Re-Inspection Process
A well-prepared re-inspection request leads to a more thorough second inspection. Each step below builds toward ensuring the re-inspection adjuster sees and documents every item the original adjuster missed.
Identify what the original adjuster missed or got wrong
Before requesting a re-inspection, be specific about what you believe needs a second look. Vague requests like "I don't agree with the estimate" are less effective than "the adjuster did not inspect the east and north slopes, where my contractor identified 23 additional hail impacts with mat fractures."
Compare the adjuster's scope of loss against your contractor's assessment item by item. Make a list of specific areas that were not inspected, damage that was present but not documented, and conditions the adjuster may have mischaracterized.
Gather supporting documentation
Your re-inspection request is stronger when you include evidence supporting each item you want re-examined. Photographs of the missed damage, your contractor's written assessment, and any relevant weather data help the carrier understand why a second inspection is justified.
If your contractor has prepared a detailed report or supplement, include it with your re-inspection request. The carrier's re-inspection adjuster can then compare their findings against your contractor's documentation in real time.
Checkpoint — you should have:
- Specific list of items the adjuster missed or got wrong
- Photos and contractor documentation for each disputed item
- Written request prepared with claim number and details
Submit a formal written request to your carrier
Call your carrier's claims department and request a re-inspection verbally, then follow up immediately with a written request. Reference your claim number, the date of the original inspection, the specific items you want re-examined, and your reason for requesting a second inspection.
Send this via email with read receipt or certified mail so you have proof of delivery. Ask for the re-inspection to be conducted by a different adjuster if possible — a fresh set of eyes may see things the original adjuster missed.
Prepare for the re-inspection day
Have your contractor present during the re-inspection. Their role is to walk the re-inspection adjuster through each disputed item, pointing out damage that was missed or mischaracterized in the original scope. This is not adversarial — it is collaborative. Your contractor is providing expert context.
Prepare a walk-through list for your contractor. Number each disputed item, include photos, and note the location on the roof. Your contractor can walk the re-inspection adjuster through each item in order, ensuring nothing is overlooked a second time.
Checkpoint — you should have:
- Written re-inspection request submitted with delivery confirmation
- Contractor arranged to be present during re-inspection
- Walk-through list prepared for the re-inspection adjuster
Review the revised scope and decide on next steps
After the re-inspection, the carrier produces a revised scope of loss. Compare it against both the original scope and your contractor's estimate. If the re-inspection closed the gap or brought it within a reasonable range, the process worked.
If a significant gap remains after the re-inspection, your next options are filing a formal supplement with the new inspection evidence, invoking the appraisal process, or engaging a public adjuster. The re-inspection documentation becomes part of your evidence for any subsequent escalation.
Your Rights During a Re-Inspection
You have the right to be present during any inspection of your property, including re-inspections. You also have the right to have your contractor or representative present. The adjuster cannot require you to leave or prevent your contractor from attending.
You have the right to request a different adjuster for the re-inspection. While the carrier is not always required to honor this request, most will send a different adjuster to provide a fresh perspective. If the original adjuster conducts the re-inspection and reaches the same conclusion without addressing your specific concerns, document that fact for potential escalation.
You have the right to request copies of the re-inspection report and photos. The carrier's documentation of the re-inspection becomes part of your claim file. If you escalate to appraisal or a DOI complaint later, this documentation is evidence.
You do not have the right to demand a specific outcome. The re-inspection may confirm the original adjuster's findings. It may find additional damage. It may reach a different causation conclusion. Your role is to ensure the re-inspection is thorough and that your documented concerns are addressed — the outcome depends on what the adjuster finds.
How to Prepare for Re-Inspection Day
Preparation is the difference between a re-inspection that changes the outcome and one that simply confirms the original findings. Walk your contractor through the specific items you want the re-inspection adjuster to examine.
Create a numbered walk-through list. Each item should include the location (e.g., "east slope, third row from ridge"), a photo of the damage, and a brief note about why it was missed or mischaracterized. Give a copy to the re-inspection adjuster at the start of the inspection so they know exactly what you want them to look at.
Have your contractor climb the roof with the adjuster. During the original inspection, your contractor may not have been present. During the re-inspection, their expertise is essential. They can point out test squares showing hail impact density, identify fracture patterns that indicate storm damage versus wear, and explain why specific conditions require replacement rather than repair.
Photograph the re-inspection process. Take photos of areas the adjuster examines, note the time spent on each slope, and document any items from your walk-through list that the adjuster addresses. This creates a record that shows the re-inspection was thorough — or reveals that it was not.
If the Re-Inspection Does Not Resolve the Dispute
A re-inspection that does not close the gap is not the end of the process. It is one step in the escalation sequence. Your documentation from both the original inspection and the re-inspection strengthens your position for the next steps.
| If the Re-Inspection... | Your Next Step | Guide |
|---|---|---|
| Found some additional damage but not all | File a supplement for remaining items | Supplement guide |
| Confirmed original scope entirely | Invoke the appraisal process | Appraisal guide |
| Disagreed on causation | Get independent causation assessment | Public adjuster guide |
| Was not thorough | File a DOI complaint about the process | DOI complaint guide |
The re-inspection is valuable even when it does not change the carrier's position. It creates an additional documented inspection that can be compared against your contractor's findings. If the two carrier inspections differ from each other, that inconsistency supports your position in appraisal or other escalation.
Check Your Understanding
You want to request a re-inspection, but you are afraid the carrier will send the same adjuster who missed the damage the first time. What should you do?
Request a different adjuster in your written re-inspection request. Most carriers will accommodate this. If they cannot, ensure your contractor is present during the re-inspection to point out each missed item directly. The key is preparation — with your contractor present and a detailed walk-through list, even the same adjuster will be shown damage they may have overlooked.
Insurance Education Disclaimer
This page provides educational guidance on the re-inspection process. Your rights and options depend on your specific policy and state regulations. This is not insurance or legal advice. Consult with your insurance professional for guidance specific to your claim.
Need a contractor to attend your re-inspection?
Southern Roofing Systems can be present during your re-inspection to ensure the adjuster sees every area of damage and produces a complete scope.
Talk to Southern Roofing Systems